## Summary
- change the cwd-change prompt (shown when resuming/forking across
different directories) so `Ctrl+C`/`Ctrl+D` exits the session instead of
implicitly selecting "Use session directory"
- introduce explicit prompt and resolver exit outcomes so this intent is
propagated cleanly through both startup resume/fork and in-app `/resume`
flows
- add a unit test that verifies `Ctrl+C` exits rather than selecting an
option
## Why
Previously, pressing `Ctrl+C` on this prompt silently picked one of the
options, which made it hard to abort. This aligns the prompt with the
expected quit behavior.
## Codex author
`codex resume 019c6d39-bbfb-7dc3-8008-1388a054e86d`
rm `remote_models` feature flag.
We see issues like #11527 when a user has `remote_models` disabled, as
we always use the default fallback `ModelInfo`. This causes issues with
model performance.
Builds on #11690, which helps by warning the user when they are using
the default fallback. This PR will make that happen much less frequently
as an accidental consequence of disabling `remote_models`.
Summary
- wait for the initial session startup loop to finish and handle exit
before waiting for the first message in fresh sessions
- propagate AppRunControl::Exit to return immediately when
initialization fails
## Summary
This PR makes app-server-provided image URLs first-class attachments in
TUI, so they survive resume/backtrack/history recall and are resubmitted
correctly.
<img width="715" height="491" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-12 at 8 27 08 PM"
src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/226cbd35-8f0c-4e51-a13e-459ef5dd1927"
/>
Can delete the attached image upon backtracking:
<img width="716" height="301" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-12 at 8 27 31 PM"
src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/4558d230-f1bd-4eed-a093-8e1ab9c6db27"
/>
In both history and composer, remote images are rendered as normal
`[Image #N]` placeholders, with numbering unified with local images.
## What changed
- Plumb remote image URLs through TUI message state:
- `UserHistoryCell`
- `BacktrackSelection`
- `ChatComposerHistory::HistoryEntry`
- `ChatWidget::UserMessage`
- Show remote images as placeholder rows inside the composer box (above
textarea), and in history cells.
- Support keyboard selection/deletion for remote image rows in composer
(`Up`/`Down`, `Delete`/`Backspace`).
- Preserve remote-image-only turns in local composer history (Up/Down
recall), including restore after backtrack.
- Ensure submit/queue/backtrack resubmit include remote images in model
input (`UserInput::Image`), and keep request shape stable for
remote-image-only turns.
- Keep image numbering contiguous across remote + local images:
- remote images occupy `[Image #1]..[Image #M]`
- local images start at `[Image #M+1]`
- deletion renumbers consistently.
- In protocol conversion, increment shared image index for remote images
too, so mixed remote/local image tags stay in a single sequence.
- Simplify restore logic to trust in-memory attachment order (no
placeholder-number parsing path).
- Backtrack/replay rollback handling now queues trims through
`AppEvent::ApplyThreadRollback` and syncs transcript overlay/deferred
lines after trims, so overlay/transcript state stays consistent.
- Trim trailing blank rendered lines from user history rendering to
avoid oversized blank padding.
## Docs + tests
- Updated: `docs/tui-chat-composer.md` (remote image flow,
selection/deletion, numbering offsets)
- Added/updated tests across `tui/src/chatwidget/tests.rs`,
`tui/src/app.rs`, `tui/src/app_backtrack.rs`, `tui/src/history_cell.rs`,
and `tui/src/bottom_pane/chat_composer.rs`
- Added snapshot coverage for remote image composer states, including
deleting the first of two remote images.
## Validation
- `just fmt`
- `cargo test -p codex-tui`
## Codex author
`codex fork 019c2636-1571-74a1-8471-15a3b1c3f49d`
[codex-generated]
## Updated PR Description (Ready To Paste)
## Problem
When a sub-agent thread emits `ShutdownComplete`, the TUI switches back
to the primary thread.
That was also happening for user-requested exits (for example `Ctrl+C`),
which could prevent a
clean app exit and unexpectedly resurrect the main thread.
## Mental model
The app has one primary thread and one active thread. A non-primary
active thread shutting down
usually means "agent died, fail back to primary," but during
`ExitMode::ShutdownFirst` shutdown
means "the user is exiting," not "recover this session."
## Non-goals
No change to thread lifecycle, thread-manager ownership, or shutdown
protocol wire format.
No behavioral changes to non-shutdown events.
## Tradeoffs
This adds a small local marker (`pending_shutdown_exit_thread_id`)
instead of inferring intent
from event timing. It is deterministic and simple, but relies on
correctly setting and clearing
that marker around exit.
## Architecture
`App` tracks which thread is intentionally being shut down for exit.
`active_non_primary_shutdown_target` centralizes failover eligibility
for `ShutdownComplete` and
skips failover when shutdown matches the pending-exit thread.
`handle_active_thread_event` handles non-primary failover before generic
forwarding and clears the
pending-exit marker only when the matching active thread completes
shutdown.
## Observability
User-facing info/error messages continue to indicate whether failover to
the main thread succeeded.
The shutdown-intent path is now explicitly documented inline for easier
debugging.
## Tests
Added targeted tests for `active_non_primary_shutdown_target` covering
non-shutdown events,
primary-thread shutdown, non-primary shutdown failover, pending exit on
active thread (no failover),
and pending exit for another thread (still failover).
Validated with:
- `cargo test -p codex-tui` (pass)
---------
Co-authored-by: Josh McKinney <joshka@openai.com>
## Why
We currently carry multiple permission-related concepts directly on
`Config` for shell/unified-exec behavior (`approval_policy`,
`sandbox_policy`, `network`, `shell_environment_policy`,
`windows_sandbox_mode`).
Consolidating these into one in-memory struct makes permission handling
easier to reason about and sets up the next step: supporting named
permission profiles (`[permissions.PROFILE_NAME]`) without changing
behavior now.
This change is mostly mechanical: it updates existing callsites to go
through `config.permissions`, but it does not yet refactor those
callsites to take a single `Permissions` value in places where multiple
permission fields are still threaded separately.
This PR intentionally **does not** change the on-disk `config.toml`
format yet and keeps compatibility with legacy config keys.
## What Changed
- Introduced `Permissions` in `core/src/config/mod.rs`.
- Added `Config::permissions` and moved effective runtime permission
fields under it:
- `approval_policy`
- `sandbox_policy`
- `network`
- `shell_environment_policy`
- `windows_sandbox_mode`
- Updated config loading/building so these effective values are still
derived from the same existing config inputs and constraints.
- Updated Windows sandbox helpers/resolution to read/write via
`permissions`.
- Threaded the new field through all permission consumers across core
runtime, app-server, CLI/exec, TUI, and sandbox summary code.
- Updated affected tests to reference `config.permissions.*`.
- Renamed the struct/field from
`EffectivePermissions`/`effective_permissions` to
`Permissions`/`permissions` and aligned variable naming accordingly.
## Verification
- `just fix -p codex-core -p codex-tui -p codex-cli -p codex-app-server
-p codex-exec -p codex-utils-sandbox-summary`
- `cargo build -p codex-core -p codex-tui -p codex-cli -p
codex-app-server -p codex-exec -p codex-utils-sandbox-summary`
There is an edge case where a directory is not readable by the sandbox.
In practice, we've seen very little of it, but it can happen so this
slash command unlocks users when it does.
Future idea is to make this a tool that the agent knows about so it can
be more integrated.
This PR adds an experimental `persist_extended_history` bool flag to
app-server thread APIs so rollout logs can retain a richer set of
EventMsgs for non-lossy Thread > Turn > ThreadItems reconstruction (i.e.
on `thread/resume`).
### Motivation
Today, our rollout recorder only persists a small subset (e.g. user
message, reasoning, assistant message) of `EventMsg` types, dropping a
good number (like command exec, file change, etc.) that are important
for reconstructing full item history for `thread/resume`, `thread/read`,
and `thread/fork`.
Some clients want to be able to resume a thread without lossiness. This
lossiness is primarily a UI thing, since what the model sees are
`ResponseItem` and not `EventMsg`.
### Approach
This change introduces an opt-in `persist_full_history` flag to preserve
those events when you start/resume/fork a thread (defaults to `false`).
This is done by adding an `EventPersistenceMode` to the rollout
recorder:
- `Limited` (existing behavior, default)
- `Extended` (new opt-in behavior)
In `Extended` mode, persist additional `EventMsg` variants needed for
non-lossy app-server `ThreadItem` reconstruction. We now store the
following ThreadItems that we didn't before:
- web search
- command execution
- patch/file changes
- MCP tool calls
- image view calls
- collab tool outcomes
- context compaction
- review mode enter/exit
For **command executions** in particular, we truncate the output using
the existing `truncate_text` from core to store an upper bound of 10,000
bytes, which is also the default value for truncating tool outputs shown
to the model. This keeps the size of the rollout file and command
execution items returned over the wire reasonable.
And we also persist `EventMsg::Error` which we can now map back to the
Turn's status and populates the Turn's error metadata.
#### Updates to EventMsgs
To truly make `thread/resume` non-lossy, we also needed to persist the
`status` on `EventMsg::CommandExecutionEndEvent` and
`EventMsg::PatchApplyEndEvent`. Previously it was not obvious whether a
command failed or was declined (similar for apply_patch). These
EventMsgs were never persisted before so I made it a required field.
`SandboxPolicy::ReadOnly` previously implied broad read access and could
not express a narrower read surface.
This change introduces an explicit read-access model so we can support
user-configurable read restrictions in follow-up work, while preserving
current behavior today.
It also ensures unsupported backends fail closed for restricted-read
policies instead of silently granting broader access than intended.
## What
- Added `ReadOnlyAccess` in protocol with:
- `Restricted { include_platform_defaults, readable_roots }`
- `FullAccess`
- Updated `SandboxPolicy` to carry read-access configuration:
- `ReadOnly { access: ReadOnlyAccess }`
- `WorkspaceWrite { ..., read_only_access: ReadOnlyAccess }`
- Preserved existing behavior by defaulting current construction paths
to `ReadOnlyAccess::FullAccess`.
- Threaded the new fields through sandbox policy consumers and call
sites across `core`, `tui`, `linux-sandbox`, `windows-sandbox`, and
related tests.
- Updated Seatbelt policy generation to honor restricted read roots by
emitting scoped read rules when full read access is not granted.
- Added fail-closed behavior on Linux and Windows backends when
restricted read access is requested but not yet implemented there
(`UnsupportedOperation`).
- Regenerated app-server protocol schema and TypeScript artifacts,
including `ReadOnlyAccess`.
## Compatibility / rollout
- Runtime behavior remains unchanged by default (`FullAccess`).
- API/schema changes are in place so future config wiring can enable
restricted read access without another policy-shape migration.
1. Move Windows Sandbox NUX to right after trust directory screen
2. Don't offer read-only as an option in Sandbox NUX.
Elevated/Legacy/Quit
3. Don't allow new untrusted directories. It's trust or quit
4. move experimental sandbox features to `[windows]
sandbox="elevated|unelevatd"`
5. Copy tweaks = elevated -> default, non-elevated -> non-admin
## Why
`codex-core` was being built in multiple feature-resolved permutations
because test-only behavior was modeled as crate features. For a large
crate, those permutations increase compile cost and reduce cache reuse.
## Net Change
- Removed the `test-support` crate feature and related feature wiring so
`codex-core` no longer needs separate feature shapes for test consumers.
- Standardized cross-crate test-only access behind
`codex_core::test_support`.
- External test code now imports helpers from
`codex_core::test_support`.
- Underlying implementation hooks are kept internal (`pub(crate)`)
instead of broadly public.
## Outcome
- Fewer `codex-core` build permutations.
- Better incremental cache reuse across test targets.
- No intended production behavior change.
## Summary
This PR fixes TUI transcript-sync behavior for
`EventMsg::ThreadRolledBack` and makes rollback application order
deterministic.
Previously, rollback handling depended on `pending_rollback`:
- if `pending_rollback` was set (local backtrack), TUI trimmed correctly
- otherwise, replayed/external rollbacks were either ignored or could be
applied at the wrong time relative to queued transcript inserts
This change keeps the local backtrack path intact and routes non-pending
rollbacks through the app event queue so rollback trims are applied in
FIFO order with transcript cell inserts.
## What changed
- Added/used `trim_transcript_cells_drop_last_n_user_turns(...)` for
rollback-by-`num_turns` semantics.
- Renamed rollback app event:
- `AppEvent::ApplyReplayedThreadRollback` ->
`AppEvent::ApplyThreadRollback`
- Replay path (`ChatWidget`) now emits `ApplyThreadRollback`.
- Live non-pending rollback path (`App::handle_backtrack_event`) now
emits `ApplyThreadRollback` instead of trimming immediately.
- App-level event handler applies `ApplyThreadRollback` after queued
`InsertHistoryCell` events and schedules redraw only when a trim
occurred.
- When a trim occurs with an overlay open, TUI now syncs transcript
overlay committed cells, clamps backtrack preview selection, and clears
stale `deferred_history_lines` so closed overlays do not re-append
rolled-back lines.
- Clarified inline comments around the `pending_rollback` branch so
future readers can reason about why there are two paths.
## Why queueing matters
During resume/replay, transcript cells are populated via queued
`InsertHistoryCell` app events. If a rollback is applied immediately
outside that queue, it can run against an incomplete transcript and
under-trim. Queueing non-pending rollbacks ensures consistent ordering
and correct final transcript state.
## Behavior by rollback source
- `pending_rollback = Some(...)` (local backtrack requested by this
TUI):
- use `finish_pending_backtrack()` and the stored selection boundary
- `pending_rollback = None` (replay/external/non-local rollback):
- enqueue `AppEvent::ApplyThreadRollback { num_turns }` and trim in
app-event order
## Tests
Added/updated tests covering ordering and semantics:
-
`app_backtrack::tests::trim_drop_last_n_user_turns_applies_rollback_semantics`
- `app_backtrack::tests::trim_drop_last_n_user_turns_allows_overflow`
- `app::tests::replayed_initial_messages_apply_rollback_in_queue_order`
-
`app::tests::live_rollback_during_replay_is_applied_in_app_event_order`
-
`app::tests::queued_rollback_syncs_overlay_and_clears_deferred_history`
- `chatwidget::tests::replayed_thread_rollback_emits_ordered_app_event`
Validation run:
- `just fmt`
- `cargo test -p codex-tui`
As of this PR, `SessionServices` retains a
`Option<StartedNetworkProxy>`, if appropriate.
Now the `network` field on `Config` is `Option<NetworkProxySpec>`
instead of `Option<NetworkProxy>`.
Over in `Session::new()`, we invoke `NetworkProxySpec::start_proxy()` to
create the `StartedNetworkProxy`, which is a new struct that retains the
`NetworkProxy` as well as the `NetworkProxyHandle`. (Note that `Drop` is
implemented for `NetworkProxyHandle` to ensure the proxies are shutdown
when it is dropped.)
The `NetworkProxy` from the `StartedNetworkProxy` is threaded through to
the appropriate places.
---
[//]: # (BEGIN SAPLING FOOTER)
Stack created with [Sapling](https://sapling-scm.com). Best reviewed
with [ReviewStack](https://reviewstack.dev/openai/codex/pull/11207).
* #11285
* __->__ #11207
There are two concepts of apps that we load in the harness:
- Directory apps, which is all the apps that the user can install.
- Accessible apps, which is what the user actually installed and can be
$ inserted and be used by the model. These are extracted from the tools
that are loaded through the gateway MCP.
Previously we wait for both sets of apps before returning the full apps
list. Which causes many issues because accessible apps won't be
available to the UI or the model if directory apps aren't loaded or
failed to load.
In this PR we are separating them so that accessible apps can be loaded
separately and are instantly available to be shown in the UI and to be
provided in model context. We also added an app-server event so that
clients can subscribe to also get accessible apps without being blocked
on the full app list.
- [x] Separate accessible apps and directory apps loading.
- [x] `app/list` request will also emit `app/list/updated` notifications
that app-server clients can subscribe. Which allows clients to get
accessible apps list to render in the $ menu without being blocked by
directory apps.
- [x] Cache both accessible and directory apps with 1 hour TTL to avoid
reloading them when creating new threads.
- [x] TUI improvements to redraw $ menu and /apps menu when app list is
updated.
- Defer rollout persistence for fresh threads (`InitialHistory::New`):
keep rollout events in memory and only materialize rollout file + state
DB row on first `EventMsg::UserMessage`.
- Keep precomputed rollout path available before materialization.
- Change `thread/start` to build thread response from live config
snapshot and optional precomputed path.
- Improve pre-materialization behavior in app-server/TUI: clearer
invalid-request errors for file-backed ops and a friendlier `/fork` “not
ready yet” UX.
- Update tests to match deferred semantics across
start/read/archive/unarchive/fork/resume/review flows.
- Improved resilience of user_shell test, which should be unrelated to
this change but must be affected by timing changes
For Reviewers:
* The primary change is in recorder.rs
* Most of the other changes were to fix up broken assumptions in
existing tests
Testing:
* Manually tested CLI
* Exercised app server paths by manually running IDE Extension with
rebuilt CLI binary
* Only user-visible change is that `/fork` in TUI generates visible
error if used prior to first turn
So that the rest of the codebase (like TUI) don't need to be concerned
whether ChatGPT auth was handled by Codex itself or passed in via
app-server's external auth mode.
## Summary
- Adds a new `/statusline` command to configure TUI footer status line
- Introduces reusable `MultiSelectPicker` component with keyboard
navigation, optional ordering and toggle support
- Implement status line setup modal that persist configuration to
config.toml
## Status Line Items
The following items can be displayed in the status line:
- **Model**: Current model name (with optional reasoning level)
- **Context**: Remaining/used context window percentage
- **Rate Limits**: 5-day and weekly usage limits
- **Git**: Current branch (with optimized lookups)
- **Tokens**: Used tokens, input/output token counts
- **Session**: Session ID (full or shortened prefix)
- **Paths**: Current directory, project root
- **Version**: Codex version
## Features
- Live preview while configuring status line items
- Fuzzy search filtering in the picker
- Intelligent truncation when items don't fit
- Items gracefully omit when data is unavailable
- Configuration persists to `config.toml`
- Validates and warns about invalid status line items
## Test plan
- [x] Run `/statusline` and verify picker UI appears
- [x] Toggle items on/off and verify live preview updates
- [x] Confirm selection persists after restart
- [x] Verify truncation behavior with many items selected
- [x] Test git branch detection in and out of git repos
---------
Co-authored-by: Josh McKinney <joshka@openai.com>
## Summary
- preserve baseline streaming behavior (smooth mode still commits one
line per 50ms tick)
- extract adaptive chunking policy and commit-tick orchestration from
ChatWidget into `streaming/chunking.rs` and `streaming/commit_tick.rs`
- add hysteresis-based catch-up behavior with bounded batch draining to
reduce queue lag without bursty single-frame jumps
- document policy behavior, tuning guidance, and debug flow in rustdoc +
docs
## Testing
- just fmt
- cargo test -p codex-tui
## Summary
Fixes#9041
- Adds update_search_dir() method to FileSearchManager to allow updating
the search directory after initialization
- Calls this method when the session CWD changes: new session, resume,
or fork
## Problem
The FileSearchManager was created once with the initial search_dir and
never updated. When a user:
1. Starts Codex in a non-git directory (e.g., /tmp/random)
2. Resumes or forks a session from a different workspace
3. The @filename lookup still searched the original directory
This caused no matches to be returned even when files existed in the
current workspace.
## Solution
Update FileSearchManager.search_dir whenever the session working
directory changes:
- AppEvent::NewSession: Use current config CWD
- SessionSelection::Resume: Use resumed session CWD
- SessionSelection::Fork: Use forked session CWD
## Test plan
- [ ] Start Codex in /tmp/test-dir (non-git)
- [ ] Resume a session from a project with actual files
- [ ] Verify @filename returns matches from the resumed session
directory
---------
Co-authored-by: Eric Traut <etraut@openai.com>
Previously, `CodexAuth` was defined as follows:
d550fbf41a/codex-rs/core/src/auth.rs (L39-L46)
But if you looked at its constructors, we had creation for
`AuthMode::ApiKey` where `storage` was built using a nonsensical path
(`PathBuf::new()`) and `auth_dot_json` was `None`:
d550fbf41a/codex-rs/core/src/auth.rs (L212-L220)
By comparison, when `AuthMode::ChatGPT` was used, `api_key` was always
`None`:
d550fbf41a/codex-rs/core/src/auth.rs (L665-L671)https://github.com/openai/codex/pull/10012 took things further because
it introduced a new `ChatgptAuthTokens` variant to `AuthMode`, which is
important in when invoking `account/login/start` via the app server, but
most logic _internal_ to the app server should just reason about two
`AuthMode` variants: `ApiKey` and `ChatGPT`.
This PR tries to clean things up as follows:
- `LoginAccountParams` and `AuthMode` in `codex-rs/app-server-protocol/`
both continue to have the `ChatgptAuthTokens` variant, though it is used
exclusively for the on-the-wire messaging.
- `codex-rs/core/src/auth.rs` now has its own `AuthMode` enum, which
only has two variants: `ApiKey` and `ChatGPT`.
- `CodexAuth` has been changed from a struct to an enum. It is a
disjoint union where each variant (`ApiKey`, `ChatGpt`, and
`ChatGptAuthTokens`) have only the associated fields that make sense for
that variant.
---
[//]: # (BEGIN SAPLING FOOTER)
Stack created with [Sapling](https://sapling-scm.com). Best reviewed
with [ReviewStack](https://reviewstack.dev/openai/codex/pull/10208).
* #10224
* __->__ #10208
Session renaming:
- `/rename my_session`
- `/rename` without arg and passing an argument in `customViewPrompt`
- AppExitInfo shows resume hint using the session name if set instead of
uuid, defaults to uuid if not set
- Names are stored in `CODEX_HOME/sessions.jsonl`
Session resuming:
- codex resume <name> lookup for `CODEX_HOME/sessions.jsonl` first entry
matching the name and resumes the session
---------
Co-authored-by: jif-oai <jif@openai.com>
## Problem
OpenAI employees were sent to the public GitHub issue flow after
`/feedback`, which is the wrong follow-up path internally.
## Mental model
After feedback upload completes, we render a follow-up link/message.
That link should be audience-aware but must not change the upload
pipeline itself.
## Non-goals
- Changing how feedback is captured or uploaded
- Changing external user behavior
## Tradeoffs
We detect employees via the authenticated account email suffix
(`@openai.com`). If the email is unavailable (e.g., API key auth), we
default to the external behavior.
## Architecture
- Introduce `FeedbackAudience` and thread it from `App` -> `ChatWidget`
-> `FeedbackNoteView`
- Gate internal messaging/links on `FeedbackAudience::OpenAiEmployee`
- Internal follow-up link is now `http://go/codex-feedback-internal`
- External GitHub URL remains byte-for-byte identical
## Observability
No new telemetry; this only changes rendered follow-up instructions.
## Tests
- `just fmt`
- `cargo test -p codex-tui --lib`
- [x] Support `/apps` slash command to browse the apps in tui.
- [x] Support inserting apps to prompt using `$`.
- [x] Lots of simplification/renaming from connectors to apps.
This PR adds a new `tui.notifications_method` config option that accepts
values of "auto", "osc9" and "bel". It defaults to "auto", which
attempts to auto-detect whether the terminal supports OSC 9 escape
sequences and falls back to BEL if not.
The PR also removes the inconsistent handling of notifications on
Windows when WSL was used.
### Motivation
- Improve UX by making it explicit that `VISUAL`/`EDITOR` must be set
before launching Codex, not during a running session.
### Description
- Update the external editor error text in `codex-rs/tui/src/app.rs` to:
`"Cannot open external editor: set $VISUAL or $EDITOR before starting
Codex."` and run `just fmt` to apply formatting.
### Testing
- Ran `just fmt` successfully; attempted `cargo test -p codex-tui` but
it failed due to network errors when fetching git dependencies (tests
did not complete).
------
[Codex
Task](https://chatgpt.com/codex/tasks/task_i_6972c2c984948329b1a37d5c5839aff3)
Fixes a TUI freeze caused by awaiting `mpsc::Sender::send()` that blocks
the tokio thread, stopping the consumption runtime and creating a
deadlock. This could happen if the server was producing enough chunks to
fill the `mpsc` fast enough. To solve this we try on insert using a
`try_send()` (not requiring an `await`) and delegate to a tokio task if
this does not work
This is a temporary solution as it can contain races for delta elements
and a stronger design should come here
## Summary
Adds /personality selector in the TUI, which leverages the new core
interface in #9644
Notes:
- We are doing some of our own state management for model_info loading
here, but not sure if that's ideal. open to opinions on simpler
approach, but would like to avoid blocking on a larger refactor
- Right now, the `/personality` selector just hides when the model
doesn't support it. we can update this behavior down the line
## Testing
- [x] Tested locally
- [x] Added snapshot tests
